In brief
- Public testimony was a rare chance to reframe his legacy, acknowledge mistakes, and show he could own hard decisions.
- Instead, Labour leader Chris Hipkins took the safer short-term path, which may prove costlier in the long run.
- His absence now defines the story his opponents will retell until polling day.
- Hipkins will now have to convince voters he’s trustworthy without the benefit of having shown public transparency over his COVID record.
A missed chance to turn the page
In November 2021, when introducing the vaccine pass legislation, then COVID Minister Chris Hipkins said: “I stand behind the Government’s record on this. We have seen one of the lowest rates of hospitalisations, one of the lowest rates of mortality, one of the best economic recoveries… The results speak for themselves.”
As Public Service Minister, Hipkins pledged he was committed to “improving openness and accountability.”
Back in March 2020, as Leader of the House, Hipkins declared: “I passionately believe in the role of Parliament in scrutinising the actions of the executive… scrutiny during this unprecedented time, when the Government is placed in the position of exercising such extraordinary powers, has never been more important.” He also promised the newly created Epidemic Response Committee would “scrutinise the government’s management of the pandemic.”
Now, Hipkins wants voters to hand him the prime minister’s job. Yet his refusal to testify publicly at the Royal Commission into New Zealand’s COVID response leaves him open to the simplest attack line: if you will not defend your record now, why should voters trust you with the future? It is a contradiction that invites suspicion of a political stitch-up. By opting out, Hipkins risks fueling the perception that Labour prefers controlled messaging over unscripted accountability.
Jacinda Ardern, Grant Robertson, and Ayesha Verrall also declined public testimony. Hipkins told Mike Hosking the group shares legal representation, a fact many see as a tacit admission that the refusal was coordinated. The visual is damning: an entire COVID leadership team sidestepping public accountability.
Inquiry chair Grant Illingworth KC could have compelled testimony but chose not to, noting the former ministers had already given evidence in private. With no procedural excuse left, Hipkins chose not to appear.
Keeping COVID alive as a campaign issue
If Labour’s strategy was to keep COVID off the 2026 campaign trail, this has backfired. The refusal ensures every COVID policy discussion between now and election day will carry the reminder that Hipkins avoided public questioning.
If Hipkins could stand at the podium day after day during the crisis, delivering lines to millions, he can hardly claim that a one-off public appearance before a commission is political theatre. National’s Judith Collins wasted no time branding the refusal “gutless and hypocritical,” twisting Hipkins’ own “1pm podium of truth” branding into a barb: “Where the hell are they now?”
ACT’s David Seymour called it “running from accountability.” These lines will live rent-free in campaign speeches, debate prep, and social media memes.
Polling by Curia for the Taxpayers’ Union found a majority of New Zealanders, including over a third of Labour voters, opposed the decision by Hipkins and other former ministers to avoid public testimony. Majorities in every other party, from National and ACT to NZ First and even Te Pāti Māori, wanted them to front the inquiry.
What does it mean when Hipkins calculated it better not to testify publicly, even though polls show many of his own supporters wanted him to?
The counter-narrative: political theatre
Supporters argue public testimony would have been political bloodletting. With an election looming, they say the format risked devolving into point scoring and grandstanding.
That defence might stand, if not for Labour’s own history. The daily 1pm COVID briefings under Ardern and Hipkins were political performances in all but name. Many suspected those sessions doubled as campaign rallies, framing Labour as New Zealand’s saviour in real time. Rejecting a single public grilling now rings hollow.
Most parties, even those now criticising him, backed the bulk of the government’s COVID actions at the time. That makes the “bloodletting” defence weaker. It was a chance to walk through his decisions. While opponents might have fought over details, most shared his framing and agreed with the thrust of many major decisions.
Editor’s note: The feature image is an AI-generated illustration. It is a satirical depiction and not a real photograph of Chris Hipkins.
Receive our free newsletter here
Hipkins’ COVID inquiry snub: Why it’s a PR disaster waiting to happen
ExclusivesComment
In brief
A missed chance to turn the page
In November 2021, when introducing the vaccine pass legislation, then COVID Minister Chris Hipkins said: “I stand behind the Government’s record on this. We have seen one of the lowest rates of hospitalisations, one of the lowest rates of mortality, one of the best economic recoveries… The results speak for themselves.”
As Public Service Minister, Hipkins pledged he was committed to “improving openness and accountability.”
Back in March 2020, as Leader of the House, Hipkins declared: “I passionately believe in the role of Parliament in scrutinising the actions of the executive… scrutiny during this unprecedented time, when the Government is placed in the position of exercising such extraordinary powers, has never been more important.” He also promised the newly created Epidemic Response Committee would “scrutinise the government’s management of the pandemic.”
Now, Hipkins wants voters to hand him the prime minister’s job. Yet his refusal to testify publicly at the Royal Commission into New Zealand’s COVID response leaves him open to the simplest attack line: if you will not defend your record now, why should voters trust you with the future? It is a contradiction that invites suspicion of a political stitch-up. By opting out, Hipkins risks fueling the perception that Labour prefers controlled messaging over unscripted accountability.
Jacinda Ardern, Grant Robertson, and Ayesha Verrall also declined public testimony. Hipkins told Mike Hosking the group shares legal representation, a fact many see as a tacit admission that the refusal was coordinated. The visual is damning: an entire COVID leadership team sidestepping public accountability.
Inquiry chair Grant Illingworth KC could have compelled testimony but chose not to, noting the former ministers had already given evidence in private. With no procedural excuse left, Hipkins chose not to appear.
Keeping COVID alive as a campaign issue
If Labour’s strategy was to keep COVID off the 2026 campaign trail, this has backfired. The refusal ensures every COVID policy discussion between now and election day will carry the reminder that Hipkins avoided public questioning.
If Hipkins could stand at the podium day after day during the crisis, delivering lines to millions, he can hardly claim that a one-off public appearance before a commission is political theatre. National’s Judith Collins wasted no time branding the refusal “gutless and hypocritical,” twisting Hipkins’ own “1pm podium of truth” branding into a barb: “Where the hell are they now?”
ACT’s David Seymour called it “running from accountability.” These lines will live rent-free in campaign speeches, debate prep, and social media memes.
Polling by Curia for the Taxpayers’ Union found a majority of New Zealanders, including over a third of Labour voters, opposed the decision by Hipkins and other former ministers to avoid public testimony. Majorities in every other party, from National and ACT to NZ First and even Te Pāti Māori, wanted them to front the inquiry.
What does it mean when Hipkins calculated it better not to testify publicly, even though polls show many of his own supporters wanted him to?
The counter-narrative: political theatre
Supporters argue public testimony would have been political bloodletting. With an election looming, they say the format risked devolving into point scoring and grandstanding.
That defence might stand, if not for Labour’s own history. The daily 1pm COVID briefings under Ardern and Hipkins were political performances in all but name. Many suspected those sessions doubled as campaign rallies, framing Labour as New Zealand’s saviour in real time. Rejecting a single public grilling now rings hollow.
Most parties, even those now criticising him, backed the bulk of the government’s COVID actions at the time. That makes the “bloodletting” defence weaker. It was a chance to walk through his decisions. While opponents might have fought over details, most shared his framing and agreed with the thrust of many major decisions.
Editor’s note: The feature image is an AI-generated illustration. It is a satirical depiction and not a real photograph of Chris Hipkins.
Receive our free newsletter here
Enjoyed this story? Share it around.
Read More
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
New Zealand is not replacing itself
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
NEWS STORIES
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
“Given increases in the international oil price…”
New Zealand is not replacing itself
“A country that cannot replace itself has no long-term sovereignty.”
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
“I’m absolutely gutted. My wife and I put 24 years into Molesworth plus this last year.”
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
“We believe in more rehabilitative, restorative justice approaches.”
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Political satire must be protected, including ugly satire. But its acceptability cannot depend on whether the target sits on the political left or right.
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
Getting off easy?
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
“Given increases in the international oil price…”
New Zealand is not replacing itself
“A country that cannot replace itself has no long-term sovereignty.”
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
“I’m absolutely gutted. My wife and I put 24 years into Molesworth plus this last year.”
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
“We believe in more rehabilitative, restorative justice approaches.”
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Political satire must be protected, including ugly satire. But its acceptability cannot depend on whether the target sits on the political left or right.
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
Getting off easy?
Sign up for our free newsletter
Receive curated lists of news links and easy-to-digest summaries from independent, alternative and mainstream media about issues affect New Zealanders.
No charges laid – 1000 days since Baby Ru’s death
Nearly three years after Baby Ru died from injuries Police said were not accidental, the case closes in on a sad milestone: three adults remain persons of interest, but still no one has been charged.
Parents do not need Big Brother to block social media
Reports of possible VPN restrictions show how quickly an under-16 social media ban can become a wider fight over digital ID, privacy and state control of the internet.
Missing vaccine meeting records expose media’s selective curiosity
When the media treat speeding tickets and political associations as accountability stories, why are missing records before a major child vaccination decision largely ignored?
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 2
The Ministry of Health has provided a detailed list of ministers and officials who it says attended a key Vaccine Ministers meeting. But it also says the meeting was not minuted and no notes exist. Another agency denies that the meeting even happened.
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 1
Official records show wording about longer Pfizer dose intervals potentially reducing myocarditis risk was removed from public communications. They do not identify who requested it or why, leaving open the question of whether science or politics guided government decision-making around vaccine safety.
TAMEEM BARAKAT: The media left out Julian Batchelor’s most surprising claim
Stuff reported my conclusion, but not the reasoning behind it.
No charges laid – 1000 days since Baby Ru’s death
Nearly three years after Baby Ru died from injuries Police said were not accidental, the case closes in on a sad milestone: three adults remain persons of interest, but still no one has been charged.
Parents do not need Big Brother to block social media
Reports of possible VPN restrictions show how quickly an under-16 social media ban can become a wider fight over digital ID, privacy and state control of the internet.
Missing vaccine meeting records expose media’s selective curiosity
When the media treat speeding tickets and political associations as accountability stories, why are missing records before a major child vaccination decision largely ignored?
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 2
The Ministry of Health has provided a detailed list of ministers and officials who it says attended a key Vaccine Ministers meeting. But it also says the meeting was not minuted and no notes exist. Another agency denies that the meeting even happened.
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 1
Official records show wording about longer Pfizer dose intervals potentially reducing myocarditis risk was removed from public communications. They do not identify who requested it or why, leaving open the question of whether science or politics guided government decision-making around vaccine safety.
TAMEEM BARAKAT: The media left out Julian Batchelor’s most surprising claim
Stuff reported my conclusion, but not the reasoning behind it.