In brief
- Tākuta Ferris judged Labour volunteers by appearance, reviving the discarded “blood quantum” test, yet aligned with those same groups when it served his interest, like opposing the Treaty Principles Bill.
- Oriini Kaipara’s 98% Māori DNA reveal was celebrated, showing how insiders can use lineage as political capital while outsiders are relegated.
- Rawiri Waititi dodged questions on Ferris by speaking only te reo during Māori Language Week, excluding 95% of New Zealanders.
- Blood and language are being used as political weapons.
Levering blood lines and language
Ferris judged race by appearance, and Waititi conveniently decided to answer questions in te reo, which allowed him to dodge scrutiny. Together, they expose a double standard at the heart of the party’s politics.
During the Tāmaki Makaurau by-election, Te Pāti Māori MP Tākuta Ferris posted a campaign image of Labour volunteers with the caption: “This blows my mind!! Indians, Asians, Black and Pākehā campaigning to take a Māori seat from Māori.”
The post was rightly decried as racist, but it also exposed a key contradiction: Ferris had no way of knowing their whakapapa. Instead, he applied the appearance test, blood quantum by another name, long condemned as a racist colonial relic. He presumed the right to judge identity by sight, as if it could be read off a face.
The irony is that Ferris, of mixed heritage himself, might not pass his own test.
Identity as a moving target
New Zealand already rejected the narrow blood test decades ago. In the 1970s, the official definition of Māori was broadened to include anyone with Māori descent, no matter how small the fraction.
The intent was to move beyond exclusion. Yet Ferris’ post did the opposite, reviving the same approach that the law moved away from half a century ago.
At the same time, insiders have continued to use ancestry as political capital. Newly elected Te Pāti Māori MP Oriini Kaipara once fronted a story about her DNA results that showed she was “98 percent Māori,” a revelation she staged on Māori Television before it became headline news across the country.
Kaipara herself said she did not see it as making her “more Māori than anyone else,” yet the media response treated her DNA as a badge of authenticity. Inside the tent, DNA percentages become proof of authenticity. Outside the tent, the same measure is denounced as racist, at least when it suits.
That is the contradiction at work.
From blood to language
The reaction to the backlash against Ferris revealed the next move. Co-leader Rawiri Waititi fronted up at Parliament for the first time since Ferris repeated his claim. Faced with questions, he refused to answer in English, citing Māori Language Week.
The tactic drew criticism across the political spectrum. Labour’s Shanan Halbert warned the party was “starting to create an exclusive bunch of Māori.”
The dodge was obvious. Later the same day, both Waititi and Debbie Ngarewa-Packer spoke in English in the House when they felt so inclined. The reo rule only applied when journalists pressed them on Ferris. In that moment, Māori Language Week was a shield, not a celebration.
However, Centrist’s question in te reo as to why Ferris’s comments were not racist when judged by the same standard they apply to others, went unanswered by the party.
According to the 2023 Census, only 4.3 percent of New Zealanders said they could hold a basic conversation in te reo. That means more than 95 percent were effectively excluded when Waititi used the language to block scrutiny.
The ordinary voter
Was it about celebrating te reo? Or was it about controlling the terms of the conversation? It appears hypocritical for Ferris to march alongside “tauiwi” (foreigners) when they are helpful in his cause, like during the fight against the Treaty Principles Bill, celebrating them as proof of unity for Te Tiriti. Yet when those same communities exercise their democratic right in Tāmaki Makaurau, he denounces them as outsiders.
[fetch_poll id=”68cdfdac23030729b115dd7e”]
Is Te Pāti Māori weaponising identity?
ExclusivesComment
In brief
Levering blood lines and language
Ferris judged race by appearance, and Waititi conveniently decided to answer questions in te reo, which allowed him to dodge scrutiny. Together, they expose a double standard at the heart of the party’s politics.
During the Tāmaki Makaurau by-election, Te Pāti Māori MP Tākuta Ferris posted a campaign image of Labour volunteers with the caption: “This blows my mind!! Indians, Asians, Black and Pākehā campaigning to take a Māori seat from Māori.”
The post was rightly decried as racist, but it also exposed a key contradiction: Ferris had no way of knowing their whakapapa. Instead, he applied the appearance test, blood quantum by another name, long condemned as a racist colonial relic. He presumed the right to judge identity by sight, as if it could be read off a face.
The irony is that Ferris, of mixed heritage himself, might not pass his own test.
Identity as a moving target
New Zealand already rejected the narrow blood test decades ago. In the 1970s, the official definition of Māori was broadened to include anyone with Māori descent, no matter how small the fraction.
The intent was to move beyond exclusion. Yet Ferris’ post did the opposite, reviving the same approach that the law moved away from half a century ago.
At the same time, insiders have continued to use ancestry as political capital. Newly elected Te Pāti Māori MP Oriini Kaipara once fronted a story about her DNA results that showed she was “98 percent Māori,” a revelation she staged on Māori Television before it became headline news across the country.
Kaipara herself said she did not see it as making her “more Māori than anyone else,” yet the media response treated her DNA as a badge of authenticity. Inside the tent, DNA percentages become proof of authenticity. Outside the tent, the same measure is denounced as racist, at least when it suits.
That is the contradiction at work.
From blood to language
The reaction to the backlash against Ferris revealed the next move. Co-leader Rawiri Waititi fronted up at Parliament for the first time since Ferris repeated his claim. Faced with questions, he refused to answer in English, citing Māori Language Week.
The tactic drew criticism across the political spectrum. Labour’s Shanan Halbert warned the party was “starting to create an exclusive bunch of Māori.”
The dodge was obvious. Later the same day, both Waititi and Debbie Ngarewa-Packer spoke in English in the House when they felt so inclined. The reo rule only applied when journalists pressed them on Ferris. In that moment, Māori Language Week was a shield, not a celebration.
However, Centrist’s question in te reo as to why Ferris’s comments were not racist when judged by the same standard they apply to others, went unanswered by the party.
According to the 2023 Census, only 4.3 percent of New Zealanders said they could hold a basic conversation in te reo. That means more than 95 percent were effectively excluded when Waititi used the language to block scrutiny.
The ordinary voter
Was it about celebrating te reo? Or was it about controlling the terms of the conversation? It appears hypocritical for Ferris to march alongside “tauiwi” (foreigners) when they are helpful in his cause, like during the fight against the Treaty Principles Bill, celebrating them as proof of unity for Te Tiriti. Yet when those same communities exercise their democratic right in Tāmaki Makaurau, he denounces them as outsiders.
[fetch_poll id=”68cdfdac23030729b115dd7e”]
Enjoyed this story? Share it around.
Read More
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
New Zealand is not replacing itself
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
NEWS STORIES
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
“Given increases in the international oil price…”
New Zealand is not replacing itself
“A country that cannot replace itself has no long-term sovereignty.”
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
“I’m absolutely gutted. My wife and I put 24 years into Molesworth plus this last year.”
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
“We believe in more rehabilitative, restorative justice approaches.”
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Political satire must be protected, including ugly satire. But its acceptability cannot depend on whether the target sits on the political left or right.
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
Getting off easy?
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
“Given increases in the international oil price…”
New Zealand is not replacing itself
“A country that cannot replace itself has no long-term sovereignty.”
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
“I’m absolutely gutted. My wife and I put 24 years into Molesworth plus this last year.”
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
“We believe in more rehabilitative, restorative justice approaches.”
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Political satire must be protected, including ugly satire. But its acceptability cannot depend on whether the target sits on the political left or right.
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
Getting off easy?
Sign up for our free newsletter
Receive curated lists of news links and easy-to-digest summaries from independent, alternative and mainstream media about issues affect New Zealanders.
No charges laid – 1000 days since Baby Ru’s death
Nearly three years after Baby Ru died from injuries Police said were not accidental, the case closes in on a sad milestone: three adults remain persons of interest, but still no one has been charged.
Parents do not need Big Brother to block social media
Reports of possible VPN restrictions show how quickly an under-16 social media ban can become a wider fight over digital ID, privacy and state control of the internet.
Missing vaccine meeting records expose media’s selective curiosity
When the media treat speeding tickets and political associations as accountability stories, why are missing records before a major child vaccination decision largely ignored?
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 2
The Ministry of Health has provided a detailed list of ministers and officials who it says attended a key Vaccine Ministers meeting. But it also says the meeting was not minuted and no notes exist. Another agency denies that the meeting even happened.
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 1
Official records show wording about longer Pfizer dose intervals potentially reducing myocarditis risk was removed from public communications. They do not identify who requested it or why, leaving open the question of whether science or politics guided government decision-making around vaccine safety.
TAMEEM BARAKAT: The media left out Julian Batchelor’s most surprising claim
Stuff reported my conclusion, but not the reasoning behind it.
No charges laid – 1000 days since Baby Ru’s death
Nearly three years after Baby Ru died from injuries Police said were not accidental, the case closes in on a sad milestone: three adults remain persons of interest, but still no one has been charged.
Parents do not need Big Brother to block social media
Reports of possible VPN restrictions show how quickly an under-16 social media ban can become a wider fight over digital ID, privacy and state control of the internet.
Missing vaccine meeting records expose media’s selective curiosity
When the media treat speeding tickets and political associations as accountability stories, why are missing records before a major child vaccination decision largely ignored?
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 2
The Ministry of Health has provided a detailed list of ministers and officials who it says attended a key Vaccine Ministers meeting. But it also says the meeting was not minuted and no notes exist. Another agency denies that the meeting even happened.
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 1
Official records show wording about longer Pfizer dose intervals potentially reducing myocarditis risk was removed from public communications. They do not identify who requested it or why, leaving open the question of whether science or politics guided government decision-making around vaccine safety.
TAMEEM BARAKAT: The media left out Julian Batchelor’s most surprising claim
Stuff reported my conclusion, but not the reasoning behind it.