In brief
- In spite of significant constraints, New Zealand universities still provide high-quality education.
- To the extent that students and parents think about the returns on investment from higher education, it is not clear that an Australian education is superior.
- In terms of returns, what matters more is the discipline studied rather than the institution.
Political activism has infiltrated educational institutions everywhere
In Part 1 of this article, I argued that New Zealand universities have become excessively politicised. Social justice activism is interfering with academic freedom and the quality of the education that we are offering our students. Negative publicity around this is one of the reasons why increasingly many students are looking overseas. Still, I think at this point in time it makes sense for students to study in New Zealand.
However, we need to recognise that when we talk about high achievers leaving, we are mostly talking about the well-off who have the financial ability to pay overseas tuition. Parents and students should be aware that the type of managerialism, social activism or problems of low morale that I discuss above are not unique to Auckland or even New Zealand. Arguably, New Zealand institutions are affected more given our perennial lack of funding and the thin margins we operate on. But going overseas does not necessarily insulate one from such afflictions.
However, anecdotal evidence suggests that, in spite of this politicisation, leading Australian schools are providing a student experience that is better than what is on offer at Auckland — for instance, smaller classes and better pastoral care. This is almost entirely due to the fact that the good Australian schools are not hurting as much in terms of government funding as we are. This allows them to offer a better product on the whole.
NZ universities are much more homogeneous than systems elsewhere. This is partly because the government uses the same funding formula for all universities here. For many New Zealand students (and the firms hiring them), there’s not much difference between a degree from Auckland or Otago. Australia likely has more variance across institutions, which means they have a better chance at selling top-tier students on the idea of attending a “top” school, as in the US.
The NCEA system bears part of the blame. The general perception is that it is not particularly rigorous and does not adequately prepare students for university and beyond. As a result, many schools offer Cambridge or IB in addition to NCEA, but these two are very much geared toward an overseas perspective; students pursuing Cambridge or IB (often coming from more privileged backgrounds) naturally gravitate toward overseas institutions.
Parents and students should still consider studying in New Zealand
By and large, parents and students consider the money spent on higher education an investment in their careers.
So, for those who have the money, is going overseas worthwhile in terms of returns on that investment?
Studying in the US or the UK, particularly the former, remains prohibitively expensive. Consequently, a lot of students are gravitating toward Australia.
Australia is certainly a bigger market than New Zealand, but it is still small compared to the US or Western Europe. Even in Australia, many students will eventually be looking for jobs elsewhere in the West or increasingly in the large Asian markets — China, India, Singapore, Hong Kong and South Korea.
It is not clear to me that a degree from (say) Sydney or Monash provides one a leg-up in these markets compared to Auckland.
What students and parents often also fail to grasp is that, by and large, across the industrialised West, the income returns to majors (e.g. business vs. humanities) far outweigh the returns to going to a more selective institution.
Students going to Australia do pay domestic fees, but they are not entitled to StudyLink, interest-free student loans or one year of free university education.
When you consider the additional expense of going to Australia, I doubt that the returns on investment outperform studying in New Zealand.
Given their very high costs, the same would be true of the US and the UK too.
This may change as New Zealand falls further behind on many measures, but at this point of time, studying in New Zealand still makes more financial sense.
Ananish Chaudhuri is Professor of Experimental Economics at the University of Auckland and author, most recently, of “Economics: A Global Introduction“.
Receive our free newsletter here
ANANISH CHAUDHURI: Why going to study overseas, particularly Australia, is not necessarily a good idea – Pt. 2
ExclusivesComment
In brief
Political activism has infiltrated educational institutions everywhere
In Part 1 of this article, I argued that New Zealand universities have become excessively politicised. Social justice activism is interfering with academic freedom and the quality of the education that we are offering our students. Negative publicity around this is one of the reasons why increasingly many students are looking overseas. Still, I think at this point in time it makes sense for students to study in New Zealand.
However, we need to recognise that when we talk about high achievers leaving, we are mostly talking about the well-off who have the financial ability to pay overseas tuition. Parents and students should be aware that the type of managerialism, social activism or problems of low morale that I discuss above are not unique to Auckland or even New Zealand. Arguably, New Zealand institutions are affected more given our perennial lack of funding and the thin margins we operate on. But going overseas does not necessarily insulate one from such afflictions.
However, anecdotal evidence suggests that, in spite of this politicisation, leading Australian schools are providing a student experience that is better than what is on offer at Auckland — for instance, smaller classes and better pastoral care. This is almost entirely due to the fact that the good Australian schools are not hurting as much in terms of government funding as we are. This allows them to offer a better product on the whole.
NZ universities are much more homogeneous than systems elsewhere. This is partly because the government uses the same funding formula for all universities here. For many New Zealand students (and the firms hiring them), there’s not much difference between a degree from Auckland or Otago. Australia likely has more variance across institutions, which means they have a better chance at selling top-tier students on the idea of attending a “top” school, as in the US.
The NCEA system bears part of the blame. The general perception is that it is not particularly rigorous and does not adequately prepare students for university and beyond. As a result, many schools offer Cambridge or IB in addition to NCEA, but these two are very much geared toward an overseas perspective; students pursuing Cambridge or IB (often coming from more privileged backgrounds) naturally gravitate toward overseas institutions.
Parents and students should still consider studying in New Zealand
By and large, parents and students consider the money spent on higher education an investment in their careers.
So, for those who have the money, is going overseas worthwhile in terms of returns on that investment?
Studying in the US or the UK, particularly the former, remains prohibitively expensive. Consequently, a lot of students are gravitating toward Australia.
Australia is certainly a bigger market than New Zealand, but it is still small compared to the US or Western Europe. Even in Australia, many students will eventually be looking for jobs elsewhere in the West or increasingly in the large Asian markets — China, India, Singapore, Hong Kong and South Korea.
It is not clear to me that a degree from (say) Sydney or Monash provides one a leg-up in these markets compared to Auckland.
What students and parents often also fail to grasp is that, by and large, across the industrialised West, the income returns to majors (e.g. business vs. humanities) far outweigh the returns to going to a more selective institution.
Students going to Australia do pay domestic fees, but they are not entitled to StudyLink, interest-free student loans or one year of free university education.
When you consider the additional expense of going to Australia, I doubt that the returns on investment outperform studying in New Zealand.
Given their very high costs, the same would be true of the US and the UK too.
This may change as New Zealand falls further behind on many measures, but at this point of time, studying in New Zealand still makes more financial sense.
Ananish Chaudhuri is Professor of Experimental Economics at the University of Auckland and author, most recently, of “Economics: A Global Introduction“.
Receive our free newsletter here
Enjoyed this story? Share it around.
Read More
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
New Zealand is not replacing itself
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
NEWS STORIES
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
“Given increases in the international oil price…”
New Zealand is not replacing itself
“A country that cannot replace itself has no long-term sovereignty.”
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
“I’m absolutely gutted. My wife and I put 24 years into Molesworth plus this last year.”
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
“We believe in more rehabilitative, restorative justice approaches.”
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Political satire must be protected, including ugly satire. But its acceptability cannot depend on whether the target sits on the political left or right.
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
Getting off easy?
Government keeps $50 fuel payment despite price trigger being met
“Given increases in the international oil price…”
New Zealand is not replacing itself
“A country that cannot replace itself has no long-term sovereignty.”
‘Station for the nation’ bid rejected as DoC picks Ngāi Tahu for Molesworth
“I’m absolutely gutted. My wife and I put 24 years into Molesworth plus this last year.”
Opportunity considers extending youth justice to ‘around 20’ after quietly dropping age 25 policy
“We believe in more rehabilitative, restorative justice approaches.”
Registered charity behind mock beheading of Peters raises double-standard questions
Political satire must be protected, including ugly satire. But its acceptability cannot depend on whether the target sits on the political left or right.
Father who filmed abuse of five-year-old daughter gets just three years and 10 months
Getting off easy?
Sign up for our free newsletter
Receive curated lists of news links and easy-to-digest summaries from independent, alternative and mainstream media about issues affect New Zealanders.
No charges laid – 1000 days since Baby Ru’s death
Nearly three years after Baby Ru died from injuries Police said were not accidental, the case closes in on a sad milestone: three adults remain persons of interest, but still no one has been charged.
Parents do not need Big Brother to block social media
Reports of possible VPN restrictions show how quickly an under-16 social media ban can become a wider fight over digital ID, privacy and state control of the internet.
Missing vaccine meeting records expose media’s selective curiosity
When the media treat speeding tickets and political associations as accountability stories, why are missing records before a major child vaccination decision largely ignored?
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 2
The Ministry of Health has provided a detailed list of ministers and officials who it says attended a key Vaccine Ministers meeting. But it also says the meeting was not minuted and no notes exist. Another agency denies that the meeting even happened.
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 1
Official records show wording about longer Pfizer dose intervals potentially reducing myocarditis risk was removed from public communications. They do not identify who requested it or why, leaving open the question of whether science or politics guided government decision-making around vaccine safety.
TAMEEM BARAKAT: The media left out Julian Batchelor’s most surprising claim
Stuff reported my conclusion, but not the reasoning behind it.
No charges laid – 1000 days since Baby Ru’s death
Nearly three years after Baby Ru died from injuries Police said were not accidental, the case closes in on a sad milestone: three adults remain persons of interest, but still no one has been charged.
Parents do not need Big Brother to block social media
Reports of possible VPN restrictions show how quickly an under-16 social media ban can become a wider fight over digital ID, privacy and state control of the internet.
Missing vaccine meeting records expose media’s selective curiosity
When the media treat speeding tickets and political associations as accountability stories, why are missing records before a major child vaccination decision largely ignored?
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 2
The Ministry of Health has provided a detailed list of ministers and officials who it says attended a key Vaccine Ministers meeting. But it also says the meeting was not minuted and no notes exist. Another agency denies that the meeting even happened.
Were ministers following the science, or the politics, on teen COVID vaccinations? Pt 1
Official records show wording about longer Pfizer dose intervals potentially reducing myocarditis risk was removed from public communications. They do not identify who requested it or why, leaving open the question of whether science or politics guided government decision-making around vaccine safety.
TAMEEM BARAKAT: The media left out Julian Batchelor’s most surprising claim
Stuff reported my conclusion, but not the reasoning behind it.